Choosing a phone
There are more than 50 phones worldwide (as of August 2010) that run versions of the Android operating system. We will list a few of the more popular models below, but here are the most important things to know before choosing an accessible phone:
1. Android version. Each phone comes with a particular version of the Android operating system. While the operating system version can be upgraded at a later date, it is up to the individual carriers to make such updates available. Since it is hard to predict when these updates will occur, you should plan on purchasing a phone that already has features that you will be happy with. The following is a list of available Android versions.
Android versions are sometimes referred to by their code names, which are generally names of desserts starting with a successive letter of the alphabet.
- Android 1.5: Cupcake
- Android 1.6: Donut
- Android 2.0 or 2.1: Eclair
- Android 2.2: Froyo (short for frozen yogurt)
- Android 2.3: Gingerbread
- Android 3.1: Honeycomb
- Android 4.0: Ice Cream Sandwich
Android 1.6 was the first version with accessibility support. Support was substantially improved in Android 2.0, and support for touchscreen-only devices was added in Android 4.0 For more information about what accessibility features were introduced in each version, see the Android Version Guide.
Carriers and device manufacturers will sometimes create customized versions of the Android operating system. For example, HTC often ships phones that include a custom user interface called HTC Sense. Unfortunately, there is no guarantee that devices with customized Android operating systems include accessibility support.
If you are wondering whether a particular device includes support for accessibility, you can check the list below. If the phone isn't listed there, it is best to check with the carrier or device manufacturer. Also, Wikipedia has a fairly comprehensive list of Android devices including information on the version number and whether or not there is a keyboard.
And be aware that even if a phone running a custom version of Android does include accessibility, the operating system may still have been altered enough that specific instructions in this guide may still not apply.
2. Keyboard and tactile buttons. Android phones come in a variety of different physical configurations. A physical QWERTY keyboard and other tactile buttons can make it easier to perform certain actions without using touch-screen controls. The following is a list of physical buttons that you might find on an Android phone:
- Start call
- End call
- Back
- Menu
- Home
- Search
- Camera
- Volume up / down
- Power
- Directional pad or trackball and select button
- QWERTY keyboard
The number of physical, tactile controls varies significantly by phone model. We recommend that you try out a phone at your local store to determine if it works well for you. If that is impossible, you can find detailed specs online and find a phone that has the keys that matter the most to you.
Some phones have touch keys, also known as capacitive keys. These keys are invisible and feel like they're part of the screen, but they're actually separate, discrete regions. The phone gives you haptic (vibrational) feedback when you press one of these keys successfully, but it can be hard to position your finger in the right place before you get the feedback. Some people put a small piece of tape over the keys to make them more tactile.
Known-accessible Android phones with "Explore by touch" (as of December 2011)
The following devices run Android 4.0 or above and are touchscreen-accessible via the "Explore by touch" feature.
- Galaxy Nexus (Android 4.0)
- The first Android device with "Explore by touch" for accessible use without a hardware keyboard.
- Has only three tactile buttons (power, volume up, and volume down). The Back, Home, Recent Apps, and Menu buttons appear at the bottom of the touchscreen and are touch explorable.
- On-screen keyboard is touch explorable.
- Very fast and powerful.
- In the U.S., available on Verizon.
Known-accessible Android phones with keyboards (as of August 2010)
The following devices are our top recommendations for accessible phones. All have full QWERTY keyboards and are known to work well. For each device we've included a description of the physical tactile buttons and any touch (capacitive) buttons and their locations on the device.
- T-Mobile G2 (Android 2.2)
- Please note: Though this phone is running the standard Android 2.2 operating system and includes accessibility support, it does not come with TalkBack pre-installed. You will have to install TalkBack from the Android Market yourself. You will be guided through this process if you go to the Accessibility menu in the Settings. For more information on this process, see the section on Enabling Accessibility.
- Four touch buttons in a row below the screen for home, menu, back, and search.
- Beneath the touch buttons, there is a square flat touchpad. You can move your finger over the touchpad to navigate left, right, up, and down. The touchpad is clickable and functions as an enter key.
- The touchpad can access everything that a directional pad can.
- Slide-out tactile keyboard with thin soft keys.
- The keyboard includes a QWERTY keyboard and tactile menu and search keys.
- The keyboard also includes three programmable tactile keys, one located on the left of the spacebar and two on the right. Pressing one of the programmable keys will take you to a menu where you can choose an application or action to be associated with the key.
- The keyboard does not have a directional pad or arrow keys.
- There is no dedicated number row at the top of the letter keys. To type numbers, you have to use the ALT keys.
- Does not have a start or end call button. However, you have the option to use the power button as the end call button. You can activate this option in the settings menu.
- The volume rocker and camera buttons are physical buttons located along the top left and bottom right sides of the phone, respectively. The power button is located along the top edge.
- The phone is very fast and powerful.
- In the U.S., available on T-Mobile.
- LG Ally (Android 2.1)
- Tactile buttons on the front for start call, home, menu, and end call. There are touch keys above those for back and search.
- Slide-out tactile keyboard with large raised keys that are very easy to type on.
- When you slide out the keyboard, you get a QWERTY keyboard, a four-direction pad with a select button in the center, and tactile buttons for back, home, menu, and search.
- Includes a dedicated number row at the top of the letter keys.
- Includes every physical button mentioned in the section above. The volume rocker and camera buttons are physical buttons located on the sides of the phone. The power button is located along the top edge.
- Moderately fast and powerful.
- In the U.S., this is available on Verizon.
- Samsung Epic 4G (Custom Android 2.1)
- Please note: This phone runs a customized version of Android 2.1. However, this phone does include support for accessibility, and TalkBack is included. But keep in mind that not all applications bundled with this phone by the carrier or Samsung are accessible. For more information on accessible applications, please see the the section on apps.
- Four touch buttons in a row below the screen for menu, home, back, and search.
- Large slide-out tactile keyboard with raised keys.
- The keyboard features a QWERTY keyboard, PC-style tactile arrow keys and a separate enter button, and tactile buttons for menu, back, home, and search.
- Includes a dedicated number row at the top of the letter keys.
- Does not have a start or end call button.
- The volume rocker and camera buttons are physical buttons located on the left and right sides of the phone respectively. The power button is located along the top edge.
- The phone is very fast and powerful.
- In the U.S., available on Sprint.
- Motorola Droid (US) / Milestone (Europe) (Android
2.2)
- Four large touch buttons in a row below the screen for back, menu, home, and search.
- Slide-out tactile keyboard, though the keys are very flat and not very easy to find by touch.
- The slide-out keyboard has a QWERTY keyboard, a four-direction pad with a select button in the center, and tactile buttons for search and menu. The four-direction pad is almost flush with the keyboard surface and can be difficult to use.
- There is no dedicated number row at the top of the letter keys. To type numbers, you have to put the keyboard in symbol mode
- Does not have a start or end call button. However, you have the option to use the power button as the end call button. You can activate this option in the settings menu.
- The volume rocker and camera buttons are physical buttons located on the right side of the phone. The power button is located along the top edge.
- The phone is very fast and powerful.
- In the U.S., this is available on Verizon.
- Motorola Droid 2 (Custom Android 2.2)
- Please note: This phone runs a customized version of Android 2.2. However, this phone does include support for accessibility, and Motorola has even included a few applications targeted for users with low or no vision. But keep in mind that not all applications bundled with this phone by the carrier or Motorola are accessible. For more information on accessible applications, please see the the section on apps.
- Four small touch buttons in a row below the screen for menu, home, back, and search.
- Slide-out tactile keyboard with raised keys.
- The keyboard features PC-style tactile arrow keys and a separate OK button.
- The keyboard includes tactile buttons for search and back. It also includes a special microphone tactile button that triggers a custom Motorola voice search application.
- There is no dedicated number row at the top of the letter keys. To type numbers, you have to put the keyboard in symbol mode.
- This device does not have a start or end call button, but you have the option to use the power button as the end call button. You can activate this option in the settings menu.
- The volume rocker and camera buttons are physical buttons located on the right side of the phone. The power button is located along the top edge.
- The phone is very fast and powerful.
- In the U.S., this is available on Verizon.
- HTC Dream / HTC G1 (Android 1.6)
- Please note: This is a first-generation phone, and it is slower and less powerful than most newer phones. Though is not expected to ever be upgraded to Android 2.0, basic accessibility features do work on Android 1.6.
- Four round tactile buttons and a clickable trackball in a row below the screen: start call, home, trackball, back, and end call. There is also a rectangular tactile menu botton located above the trackball. When held down, the end call button functions as the power on/off button.
- The trackball can access everything that a directional pad can, but it can be difficult to move it precisely without being able to see the screen.
- Slide-out tactile keyboard with thin but raised keys.
- The keyboard includes a QWERTY keyboard and tactile menu and search keys.
- Includes a dedicated number row at the top of the letter keys.
- Includes every physical button mentioned in the section above. The volume rocker and camera buttons are physical buttons located on the sides of the phone. The power button is located on the front and doubles as the end call button.
- In the U.S., this is available on T-Mobile.
Phones with keyboards - accessibility unknown
- Motorola Droid Pro (Unreleased)
- Accessibility unknown - please let us know if you've tried it.
- Motorola CHARM (Android 2.1)
- In the U.S., available on T-Mobile.
- Accessibility unknown - please let us know if you've tried it.
- T-Mobile MyTouch 3G Slide (Custom Android 2.1)
- This is an example of a phone with a custom operating system. However, some users have reported that they have been able to use it successfully. If you have more specific information, let us know.
- If the same phone, the HTC Espresso, is sold elsewhere in the world with an accessible version of Android, please let us know.
- Motorola Devour (Android 1.6)
- In the U.S., available on Verizon.
- Accessibility unknown - please let us know if you've tried it.
- Samsung Intercept (Android 2.1)
- In the U.S., available on Sprint.
- Accessibility unknown - please let us know if you've tried it.
Phones with keyboards that may not be accessible
The following phones have QWERTY keyboards but are known to have accessibility issues.
- Motorola CLIQ / DEXT (Android 1.5)
- Android 1.5 has no accessibility features.
- Motorola Backflip (Android 1.5)
- Android 1.5 has no accessibility features.
- LG InTouch Max (Android 1.5)
- Android 1.5 has no accessibility features.
Phones without keyboards
With the exception of devices running Android 4.0 and above, we do not recommend Android phones without keyboards for accessibility. For your reference, here is a partial list of some of the more popular Android phones that do not have a keyboard.
- Acer (all models)
- Dell (all models)
- Garminfone
- GeeksPhone One
- General Mobile DSTL1
- HTC Aria
- HTC Desire
- HTC Droid Eris
- HTC Droid Incredible
- HTC EVO 4G
- HTC Hero
- HTC Magic / T-mobile MyTouch
- HTC Tattoo
- Huawei U8230
- Lenovo LePhone
- LG Optimus
- Motorola CLIQ XT
- Motorola Droid X
- Motorola i1
- Nexus One
- Samsung Behold 2
- Samsung Captivate
- Samsung Galaxy
- Samsung Galaxy S
- Samsung Moment
- Samsung Vibrant
- Sony Ericsson Xperia X10
- Sony Ericsson Xperia X10 Mini
- T-Mobile Pulse
- T-Mobile Pulse Mini
If you have any information about other Android phones that are or are not accessible, please let us know!